Instar Asset Management and Windmill Farms: Poor Labor Practices and Poor Returns

Asset Management, PERSist,

By: Frank V. Líma, International Association of Fire Fighters

Worked meeting with management on a factory floor

Institutional investors across the U.S. have a clear choice: treat workforce issues as a box to check, or recognize them for what they are — a direct sign of business quality, operational discipline, and long-term investor value. When workers are mistreated, the risks to the institution do not stay contained. They often become lawsuits, fines, disruptions, reputational damage, and weak returns. That is why institutional investors, such as private equity managers, must set clear expectations on how workplace issues are reviewed and managed.

Institutional investors who acquire companies have a moral and fiduciary obligation to set these expectations. Without that clarity, private equity managers may be rewarded for cutting corners, even as those shortcuts put both workers and investors at risk. The experience of Windmill Farms and their private equity owner, Instar Asset Management, shows why creating a cooperative relationship with the workforce is needed.

Instar Asset Management acquired Windmill Farms, a mushroom growing operation, through its second infrastructure fund. Since then, Instar has neglected to address serious workforce problems and failed to deliver strong results for investors. As Instar fundraises for its third infrastructure fund, potential investors should ask a basic but important question: How will Instar prevent another Windmill Farms?

The threat is not theoretical. Take, for instance, the Texas Municipal Retirement System (TMRS). TMRS reports poor returns from two investments in Instar’s second infrastructure fund. The TMRS website’s most recent report shows the two investments providing a -7.51% and -.14% Internal Rate of Return (IRR), respectively. After nearly seven years, the fund shows a loss of over $11 million.

A report by the University of Oregon Labor Education and Research Center, Instar Asset Management Continues to Disappoint Investors, provides details on the firm’s performance concerns and reputational challenges.

The report makes the connection clear: labor problems can become investment problems. Since Instar’s acquisition of Windmill Farms, the farm has been fined by the U.S. Department of Labor for unpaid wages and other federal violations; settled a discrimination lawsuit with the Washington State Attorney General for $3.4 million; been sued by numerous employees for alleged federal and state violations; refused to meet with farmworker representatives and numerous civic organizations concerned about the treatment of Windmill workers; faced calls for Instar to be removed from the Principles for Responsible Investment (PRI) due to violating its own Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) policies; and been the subject of a growing boycott of the farm’s products by the United Farm Workers, which has been endorsed by international labor, religious, and civic groups. This almost four-year-long labor dispute continues to create financial and reputational risks for the farm, its private equity owner, and Instar investors.

A Growing Investor Response Towards Workforce Principles

Major public pension funds, including state pension funds managing over a trillion dollars in combined retirement assets, have adopted Responsible Workforce Management policies to help protect value and reduce risk in their private equity portfolios, including New York State Common, Maryland, Massachusetts, Illinois, and CalPERS.

These policies give investors a practical way to both ask better questions before committing capital, and to spot problems before they grow. By integrating better workforce policies into manager selection, due diligence, and monitoring, investors can better understand labor-related risks within their portfolios. This is especially important in private equity, where there is a higher risk of bankruptcy, which often results in layoffs and other workforce harms.

The business case is straightforward and compelling: companies that invest in their workers are often better positioned to perform for investors. Research shows that more fair wages and better benefits support value creation. Deloitte found that companies with a program to manage workforce risk reported better performance. Implementing good health and safety practices can also reduce costs associated with workers’ compensation payments, medical expenses, and lost productivity. A Glass Lewis analysis of shareholder engagements found that companies’ “approach to labor rights issues can significantly influence the overall business landscape and ultimately affect investor returns.”

Conversely, poor workforce relations can lead to operational disruptions, litigation, fines, substandard work, and reputational harm that can have material impacts on performance. Work stoppages can be costly and can extend far beyond a single company, with broad economic impacts. Without strong oversight, risks may go undetected until they have already harmed workers, businesses, and investor returns.

Fire Fighters Care Deeply About Strong Pensions and Fair Treatment of Workers

The International Association of Fire Fighters (IAFF) represents nearly 370,000 members and has been outspoken about the situation at Windmill Farms because the issue matters to workers and retirement security. Our union represents members of the TMRS system, and we have raised serious concerns with the pension fund about Instar Asset Management’s continued underperformance.

Farm workers are some of the most exploited workers in the US and Canada, and the United Farm Workers (UFW) has a strong history of standing up for them, just like the IAFF does for fire fighters. IAFF members keep their communities safe. UFW members keep our country fed. We must stand together to protect workers’ rights and strong pensions. Workers at Windmill Farms are simply asking for fair treatment on the job. Investors and asset managers should support them, not only because it is the right thing to do, but because businesses that respect and invest in their workers are more likely to perform better and build lasting value than those that cut corners.

Investor-led oversight is not just a policy preference: it is a necessary safeguard for workers, businesses, retirement systems, and investors. As more funds adopt workforce principles, investors have an opportunity to send a clear message: long-term value and strong investment returns depend on responsible management, fair treatment of workers, and accountability when those standards are not met.

Frank V. Líma, General Secretary/Treasurer, International Association of Fire Fighters, is a dedicated family man, Los Angeles City fire captain, and lifelong grassroots labor leader driven by his credo: “UNITE, FIGHT and ORGANIZE”. Joining the Los Angeles City Fire Department (LAFD) in 1992, he rose through the ranks to truck company captain, serving in hazardous materials and USAR units. His frontline response includes deployments to Ground Zero on September 11 and Hurricane Katrina.

Líma’s personal encounter with an unjust termination threat fueled his passion for union advocacy. He served as president of UFLAC Local 112, achieving pay parity for members, growing assets by over 200%, and blocking hazardous cell towers.

Elected as the IAFF 12th General Secretary-Treasurer in 2021, Líma has championed financial accountability, clean audits, and pension reforms projected to save $75 million. Backed by his wife, Lisa, and their family, he continues to defend union workers nationwide.